Why Brian McDermott Axed Super League's Best Player When England Needed Him Most

Why Brian McDermott Axed Super League's Best Player When England Needed Him Most

Brian McDermott made a ruthless call in Wollongong. With England staring down the barrel of an early exit from the 2026 Men's Rugby League World Cup, the head coach dropped reigning Man of Steel Brad O'Neill from his matchday 19 entirely, promoting Hull KR hooker Jez Litten to the starting number nine jersey and restoring Morgan Knowles at loose forward.

On the surface, axing the newly crowned Super League player of the year for a must-win Group B-C clash against Papua New Guinea looks like panic. It is anything but. The decision exposes the brutal mathematical reality of England's tournament predicament, where a simple victory over the Kumuls is practically worthless unless it comes with an avalanche of points.

The Mathematical Trap Behind the Selection

To understand why Brad O'Neill found himself watching from the stands as a reserve rather than steering England from dummy-half, you have to look at the Group B-C table. England blew their margin for error on opening weekend in Perth, stumbling to a 30-12 defeat against Tonga after coughing up possession and conceding cheap penalties despite dominating the early exchanges of both halves.

Even after dismantling a hopelessly outmatched France side 82-0 in their second outing, England walked into the final round of pool play trapped in a vice. Because of their head-to-head loss to Tonga, an upset win by Samoa over Tonga eliminates England immediately regardless of what happens in Wollongong. Assuming Tonga does England a favor by beating Samoa, qualification comes down to points difference between England and the Samoans.

Going into the final round, England trailed Samoa by a staggering 68 points.

You do not erase a 68-point deficit against a physical, hard-nosed Papua New Guinea outfit by playing conservative, attritional football. You need speed around the ruck, relentless tempo, and a bench built to blow a tiring defensive line apart in the final quarter. That specific tactical demand turned O'Neill's greatest strengths into temporary liabilities.

Why O'Neill Lost Out to Litten and Lewis

Brad O'Neill won the 2026 Man of Steel award on the back of his durability, defensive steel, and crisp distribution for Wigan Warriors. At 24 years old, he is a classic 80-minute controller. When you are defending a narrow lead in a wet October night in Lancashire, O'Neill is the first name on the team sheet.

Wollongong in late October requires a different weapon.

Jez Litten operates on a completely different frequency out of dummy-half. When Litten came off the interchange bench against France, he immediately injected pace into England's ruck speed, capped by his 58th-minute try. Litten darts out of the pocket on half-breaks, forces markers to square up, and keeps opposing middle forwards retreating on their heels. Against a Papua New Guinea pack that thrives on big collisions and slow play-the-balls, Litten's running threat is the skeleton key.

Once McDermott committed to Litten starting at hooker, O'Neill's spot on the bench vanished instantly. Carrying a second specialist hooker on a four-man interchange when chasing a 68-point swing makes zero tactical sense. Instead, McDermott kept Hull KR dynamo Mikey Lewis in the number 14 jersey. Lewis—who famously missed out on the opener against Tonga before returning to the bench against France—gives England an explosive, unpredictable running threat capable of spelling Litten at dummy-half or slotting into the halves to create broken-field chaos.

O'Neill was not dropped because he played poorly. He was squeezed out by a mathematical equation that demanded maximum attacking volatility over 80 minutes.

The Morgan Knowles Factor and the Radley Tradeoff

While O'Neill's omission grabbed the headlines, McDermott's second major adjustment in the engine room carries just as much tactical weight. Morgan Knowles returned to the starting lineup at lock, pushing Victor Radley out of the starting 13.

Radley had worn the number 13 shirt during the 82-0 demolition of France, a match where his ball-playing at the line helped slice open a porous defense. Papua New Guinea presents a vastly more violent defensive proposition. Kumuls forwards hit hard, shoot out of the line to cut down time and space, and punish lateral ball movement.

Knowles brings an entirely different brand of utility to the middle third. Rather than acting as a third halfback like Radley, Knowles plays like a traditional, high-motor British loose forward. He wins the contact zone, generates quick play-the-balls through sheer leg drive, and shores up the defensive channel right next to halfbacks George Williams and Harry Smith.

By pairing Knowles's directness at lock with Litten's speed at hooker, McDermott redesigned England's spine to win the ruck first and ask questions wide second. If England cannot bend the PNG line through the middle, outside strike weapons like Herbie Farnworth—fresh off a hat-trick against France—and winger Dominic Young will never see clean front-foot ball.

The Bench Gamble That Signals All-Out Attack

Look closely at the rest of McDermott's 17-man squad for the Kumuls clash, and the blueprint becomes unmistakable. Alongside Mikey Lewis at 14, England loaded the interchange with heavy artillery in Sam Walters, Ethan Havard, and veteran utility Kallum Watkins, leaving Victor Radley out of the final 17 altogether despite earlier expectations he might drop to the bench.

That bench configuration tells you everything about how England plans to survive the first 30 minutes and win the last 50.

Starting props Max King and Luke Thompson have one job—absorb the initial physical ambush from Epel Kapinias and the PNG middle without conceding cheap field position. Once the early storm passes and fatigue sets into the Kumuls' big men, Havard and Walters enter the fray to maintain size while Lewis comes on to turn tired forwards inside out around the ruck.

There is obvious risk baked into this gamble. Without O'Neill's defensive organization or Radley's ball-playing link work, England's middle third relies heavily on Litten enduring a massive workload against bruising tacklers. If Litten gets targeted early or picks up a knock, Lewis has to cover hooker for extended minutes, stripping England of their primary bench x-factor.

McDermott knows the stakes. Playing safe in Wollongong guarantees a flight home to Manchester. By sidelining the reigning Man of Steel for Litten's pace and restoring Knowles to anchor the pack, England's coach finally stopped coaching to avoid losing and started coaching to blow the doors off the scoreboard.

IG

Isabella Gonzalez

As a veteran correspondent, Isabella Gonzalez has reported from across the globe, bringing firsthand perspectives to international stories and local issues.