Why Israel Cannot Seem to Form a Stable Government

Why Israel Cannot Seem to Form a Stable Government

Israel's electoral math is broken by design. Because the country operates on a pure proportional representation system with a single nationwide district and a low 3.25% electoral threshold, no single party has ever won an outright majority in the 120-seat Knesset since the state was founded in 1948. Every government is a fragile coalition of strange bedfellows, leaving the entire administration vulnerable to collapse the moment a minor faction decides its demands aren't being met.

When foreign observers watch Israeli election nights, they tend to look at the top-line winners and assume the hard part is over. They are wrong. In Jerusalem, election night is merely the opening bell for weeks of ruthless, zero-sum horse-trading where a party with four seats holds the exact same veto power over a coalition's survival as a party with thirty.

The Structural Trap of Pure Proportionality

To understand why Israel's election results routinely produce political paralysis, you have to look at the ballot box itself. Unlike the United States or the United Kingdom, Israel has no geographic constituencies. Voters do not elect a local representative to look after their district's roads or schools. Instead, the entire country acts as one giant electoral pool, and citizens cast a single vote for a closed party list.

If a party clears the 3.25% electoral threshold—which translates to roughly four seats in the 120-seat Knesset—it enters parliament. That low bar was originally intended to ensure that every slice of Israel's deeply fractured society had a voice at the table. Secular leftists, ultra-Orthodox Haredim, religious Zionists, Russian-speaking immigrants, and Palestinian citizens of Israel could all form their own parties and secure representation.

In practice, it turned the Knesset into a perpetual stalemate machine.

Because a winning coalition requires at least 61 seats, the leader of the largest party must stitch together four, five, or sometimes even eight different factions just to get a governing majority. Imagine trying to pass a national budget when your coalition includes free-market secularists who want to cut welfare subsidies alongside ultra-Orthodox parties whose entire voter base relies on state stipends for full-time religious study. Every policy decision becomes an existential crisis.

The Kingmaker Effect

This math creates what veteran Israeli political analysts call the kingmaker effect. When two major blocs are deadlocked at around 55 to 58 seats each, the smallest parties become the most powerful actors in the room.

To illustrate how this plays out, consider a hypothetical scenario based on standard Knesset arithmetic. Suppose a center-right bloc wins 58 seats and a center-left bloc wins 56 seats. Sitting in the middle is a small sectarian party with just 6 seats. Neither major bloc can govern without them. That 6-seat party can suddenly demand the Finance Ministry, massive budget allocations for its specific institutions, and veto power over judicial appointments—all while representing less than five percent of the electorate.

If the Prime Minister refuses, the small party walks out, the coalition drops below 61 seats, and the country is plunged back into another multi-billion-shekel election cycle.

Beyond Left and Right

Foreign media outlets love to frame Israeli politics as a simple tug-of-war between the "left" and the "right" over peace with the Palestinians and territorial concessions. That framing is at least twenty years out of date. While security and the conflict remain central to the national psyche, the actual fault lines tearing Israeli coalitions apart are far more tribal and institutional.

Today, the Knesset is divided along four overlapping axes that refuse to align neatly.

  • The Pro- and Anti-Netanyahu Divide. For over a decade, the single most potent organizing principle in Israeli politics has not been ideology, but personal loyalty or opposition to Benjamin Netanyahu. Right-wing politicians who agree with Netanyahu on almost every economic and security policy have repeatedly refused to sit in his governments due to his ongoing corruption trials and their personal distrust of him. This split alone paralyzed the country through five elections between 2019 and 2022.
  • Religion and State. Israel has no formal constitution, operating instead on a collection of Basic Laws and a delicate, decades-old status quo agreement governing religious life. Questions over whether ultra-Orthodox men should be drafted into the military, whether public transit should run on the Sabbath, and who controls marriage and conversion laws routinely blow up coalitions from the inside.
  • The Judicial Power Struggle. A massive rift exists over the role of the Supreme Court. One camp views the court as the essential guardrail protecting minority rights in a country without a constitution or an upper legislative chamber. The other camp views it as an unelected, self-perpetuating elite that routinely overrides the will of the elected parliament.
  • The Integration of Arab Parties. Palestinian citizens make up roughly 20% of Israel's population, yet for decades, Arab-led parties were treated as untouchable by mainstream Zionist coalitions. When the Islamist Ra'am party broke that taboo in 2021 to join a diverse governing coalition, it proved that Arab-Jewish political partnership was possible—and immediately triggered a fierce nationalist backlash that helped bring that same government down a year later.

When you overlay these four divides onto a 120-seat parliament, the mathematical combinations required to reach 61 seats shrink to almost zero. You can have two parties that agree completely on security policy, yet cannot sit together because one is secular and the other is ultra-Orthodox. You can have two parties that agree on economic reform, yet refuse to speak because one wants to overhaul the judiciary and the other wants to protect it.

The Dead-End of Electoral Reform

Whenever an Israeli election ends in chaos, pundits immediately call for electoral reform. The proposed fixes always sound neat on paper. Raise the electoral threshold to 5% or 6% to wipe out the small kingmaker parties. Introduce regional districts so lawmakers are accountable to local voters rather than party bosses. Switch to a presidential system where the executive is directly elected and cannot be toppled by a parliamentary no-confidence vote.

Israel actually tried one of these fixes in the 1990s, and it was an unmitigated disaster.

Between 1996 and 2001, Israel adopted a direct election system for the Prime Minister. Voters were given two ballots: one for the person they wanted as Prime Minister, and one for the party they wanted in the Knesset. The logic seemed sound. Give the Prime Minister a direct popular mandate so small parties couldn't hold them hostage.

Instead, voters split their tickets. They voted for their preferred candidate for Prime Minister on the first ballot, and then voted for narrow, single-issue sectarian parties on the second ballot. The two major parties—Likud and Labor—hemorrhaged seats, while small religious and immigrant parties exploded in size. Far from stabilizing the government, the reform weakened the Prime Minister's party base so severely that the Knesset quickly repealed the law and went back to the old system.

Why the System Refuses to Fix Itself

The fundamental catch-22 of Israeli electoral reform is that the very parties benefiting from the broken system are the ones who have to vote to change it.

Raising the threshold to 6% would effectively eliminate smaller ideological and minority factions from the Knesset. Naturally, those factions will never vote for their own political extinction, and any major party that threatens to push such a reform immediately loses the coalition partners it needs to govern. Even the idea of introducing regional districts hits a demographic wall, as many Israelis worry that geographic voting would either gerrymander Arab communities out of representation or hand disproportionate power to specific enclaves.

The Hidden Cost of Constant Campaigning

The messiness of Israeli election results is not just a parlor game for political junkies; it has severe, tangible consequences for how the country is run. When a government knows it might collapse within eighteen months, long-term governance dies.

Ministries are routinely carved up and handed out as political trophies rather than based on administrative competence. To satisfy a dozen different coalition partners, Prime Ministers have repeatedly bloated the cabinet to absurd proportions, creating redundant ministries with overlapping jurisdictions—such as splitting water resources, energy, and environmental protection across three separate offices just to give three different lawmakers a ministerial title and a budget.

Worse still is the budgetary paralysis. Under Israeli law, if a government fails to pass a national budget by a strict deadline, the Knesset automatically dissolves and triggers new elections. Because passing a budget requires every coalition partner to sign off on spending cuts and allocations, factions routinely use the budget deadline as a loaded gun pointed at the Prime Minister's head. During periods of prolonged deadlock, the country is forced to operate on a rolling, pro-rated version of the previous year's budget, freezing new infrastructure projects, delaying social programs, and leaving critical ministries starved of updated funding.

Civil servants—the professional bureaucrats who actually keep the state running—find themselves serving a revolving door of ministers who are more focused on preparing for the next primary campaign than fixing systemic problems in healthcare, education, or housing.

What Actually Decides the Winner

If the raw seat count on election night doesn't tell the whole story, what does? To read an Israeli election accurately, you have to ignore the headlines about who "won" the most seats and look at three specific mechanics instead.

First, look at the wasted vote count. Because of the 3.25% threshold, a party that finishes at 3.1% gets zero seats. Those tens of thousands of votes simply vanish into thin air, artificially inflating the seat counts of the parties that did cross the line. In several recent Israeli elections, a major bloc lost its majority not because the public turned against it, but because two small allied parties refused to merge before the deadline, both fell just short of 3.25%, and collectively threw away over 250,000 votes.

Second, watch the surplus-vote agreements. Before election day, parties pair up and sign legal agreements to pool their leftover votes—the fractional remainders that aren't quite enough to earn a full seat on their own. Under the Bader-Ofer method, these combined remainders often grant an extra seat to one of the paired parties. A single seat swung by a surplus-vote deal frequently determines whether a coalition reaches 61 or stalls at 60.

Third, track the presidential consultations. Once the final tally is certified, the President of Israel—a largely ceremonial head of state—holds televised consultations with every party leader in the Knesset. Each party recommends who they think should get the first crack at forming a government. The President then hands the mandate to the candidate with the highest likelihood of assembling 61 seats, starting a strict 28-day clock (with a possible 14-day extension) to strike the necessary deals.

If that candidate fails, the mandate can be handed to a rival, or tossed to the Knesset as a whole for a chaotic 21-day free-for-all where any lawmaker who can gather 61 signatures becomes Prime Minister.

There is no clean sweep waiting at the end of an Israeli ballot count. Until the country finds a way to rewrite the basic arithmetic of its parliament, every election night will remain just the opening act of a much longer, much uglier negotiation over who actually holds the keys to the state.

IG

Isabella Gonzalez

As a veteran correspondent, Isabella Gonzalez has reported from across the globe, bringing firsthand perspectives to international stories and local issues.