Could A Major Part Of Brexit Actually Be Reversed

Could A Major Part Of Brexit Actually Be Reversed

Yes, significant components of Brexit can be reversed, though not through a sudden return to full European Union membership. Instead, political analysts, trade economists, and diplomatic observers point toward a quieter, piecemeal realignment. Rather than rejoining the Single Market or the Customs Union outright—moves that both the UK government and Brussels currently view as politically unviable—reversing parts of Brexit involves targeted bilateral agreements. These include veterinary and sanitary deals to ease food trade, mutual recognition of professional qualifications, security pacts, and youth mobility schemes.

The conversation has shifted from existential constitutional battles to granular, sector-by-sector negotiations. Since the UK formally left the EU in January 2020 and exited the transition period a year later under the Trade and Cooperation Agreement (TCA), the practical friction of non-membership has become an everyday reality for British exporters, European logistics firms, and border authorities. Under Prime Minister Keir Starmer's Labour government, which took office in July 2024 with a mandate to "reset" relations with Europe, the focus has moved away from ideological purity toward reducing non-tariff barriers. Yet every step closer to Brussels carries a strict price tag set by the European Commission, creating a complex diplomatic puzzle where domestic British red lines collide with the EU's institutional rules.

The Anatomy of a Quiet Reversal

To understand what can realistically be undone, one must look at the architecture of the TCA itself. Unlike permanent treaties that sit untouched for decades, the TCA was built with a mandatory five-year review clause, coming into sharp focus in 2026. Brussels has repeatedly stated that this review is meant to ensure the existing agreement is being properly implemented, not to rewrite its foundations. However, British policymakers and trade associations view the surrounding diplomatic momentum as an opening to layer new, supplementary agreements onto the existing framework.

The most immediate target for reversal is border friction affecting agri-food products. Currently, shipments of meat, dairy, and plants moving between Great Britain and the EU require extensive Export Health Certificates, physical inspections, and customs declarations. Industry groups such as the British Retail Consortium and the Food and Drink Federation have documented how these checks add billions of pounds in administrative costs and cause perishable goods to spoil at ports like Dover and Calais.

A Sanitary and Phytosanitary (SPS) agreement, modeled loosely on the arrangement Switzerland maintains with the EU, would eliminate the vast majority of these border checks. By aligning British food, plant, and animal health standards with European rules, goods could flow across the English Channel with minimal paperwork. In practical terms, this would also dismantle much of the remaining trade barrier in the Irish Sea under the Windsor Framework, easing long-standing political tensions in Northern Ireland.

The Regulatory Alignment Dilemma

The catch is sovereignty, the very issue that drove the 2016 referendum. The European Union operates on a strict legal hierarchy: a non-member cannot enjoy the frictionless benefits of the Single Market without accepting the rules that govern it and the courts that enforce them.

For an SPS deal to function, the UK would have to become a "rule-taker" in agricultural and food safety standards. If Brussels bans a specific pesticide or updates packaging regulations, London would have to follow suit automatically or risk the suspension of trade privileges. Furthermore, the European Commission insists that any dispute over EU law must ultimately be adjudicated by the European Court of Justice (ECJ). For British politicians who campaigned on "taking back control" of UK laws and borders, accepting dynamic alignment and ECJ oversight remains a toxic prospect, even in narrow technical sectors.

Where the Economic Pressure Is Highest

While political rhetoric often treats Brexit as a binary choice—in or out—the economic impact has been unevenly distributed across industries. Certain sectors have absorbed the shock, while others are actively lobbying to reverse specific post-Brexit rules that threaten their viability.

  • Chemical Manufacturing: Under the EU's REACH (Registration, Evaluation, Authorisation and Restriction of Chemicals) framework, companies must register chemical substances to sell them in Europe. Following Brexit, the UK established its own parallel system, UK REACH. Chemical giants like BASF and INEOS, alongside the Chemical Industries Association, have warned that duplicating safety data for the British market costs the industry upwards of £2 billion without adding any environmental or health benefits. Re-integrating into the EU's regulatory database is one of the highest priorities for British industrialists.
  • Touring Artists and Creative Industries: Before 2021, British musicians, crew members, and theater companies could travel across Europe seamlessly. Today, they face a patchwork of national work permits, cabotage rules restricting how many stops a British tour bus can make in the EU, and ATA Carnets—expensive customs passports required for musical instruments and stage equipment. Cultural organizations have pushed aggressively for a bilateral visa waiver and cultural touring exemption, arguing that the current rules are hollowing out the UK's talent pipeline.
  • Professional Services and Financial Equivalence: While the City of London avoided the catastrophic exodus predicted by some commentators in 2016, British architects, lawyers, and accountants lost automatic recognition of their qualifications across the 27 member states. Reversing this requires tedious, profession-by-profession negotiations between regulatory bodies on both sides of the Channel.
  • Defense and Security Cooperation: Notably, the original TCA contained almost no formal provisions for foreign policy or defense cooperation, a deliberate choice by Boris Johnson's government at the time. Geopolitical realities—specifically the war in Ukraine and shifting security dynamics in Washington—have made that omission look increasingly untenable. Both London and Brussels are actively building a formal UK-EU Security Pact that would integrate the UK into European defense procurement, intelligence sharing, and joint military exercises.

The Youth Mobility Standoff

If London has a shopping list of trade irritants it wants removed, Brussels has its own demands. European leaders have made it clear that they will not engage in what they call "cherry-picking"—granting the UK better market access in areas where Britain holds a competitive advantage without receiving something substantial in return.

At the top of the European Commission's wishlist is a Youth Mobility Scheme. Proposed by Brussels in April 2024, the plan would allow British and EU citizens aged 18 to 30 to live, study, and work in each other's territories for up to four years without being subject to high visa fees or student surcharges. The UK already operates similar bilateral schemes with countries like Australia, Canada, and Japan, though those are capped in numbers and require participants to prove they have sufficient savings.

Brussels wants an uncapped arrangement that looks much closer to a mini-version of free movement. For the UK government, this is a political minefield. Net migration became a dominant issue in British politics following the post-Brexit surge in non-EU immigration, and Starmer's administration explicitly ruled out returning to free movement. Conservative opponents and Nigel Farage's Reform UK stand ready to weaponize any youth mobility deal as a betrayal of the 2016 referendum result, framing it as free movement through the back door.

European diplomats, however, view the British refusal as shortsighted. From their perspective, a youth mobility agreement is not a revival of free movement; it is a standard diplomatic tool that addresses labor shortages in the UK's hospitality and agricultural sectors while restoring opportunities lost by young people on both sides. Without movement on youth mobility or fishing rights—another perennial flashpoint as the initial post-Brexit quotas expire in June 2026—EU member states like France and Spain have little incentive to grant London concessions on food exports or chemical regulations.

The Structural Reality of the Single Market

A persistent misconception in the British debate is the idea that the UK could rejoin the Customs Union while staying outside the Single Market, or vice versa, to capture most of the economic benefits without the political fallout. Trade experts consistently point out why this middle ground is structurally flawed.

A customs union eliminates tariffs and rules-of-origin paperwork on goods traded between members, while establishing a common external tariff for imports from the rest of the world. However, tariffs are not the primary barrier holding back UK-EU trade today; the TCA already provides for zero-tariff, zero-quota trade on goods. The real obstacle is non-tariff barriers—regulatory checks, product standards, and safety certifications. A customs union alone does not remove those checks. Trucks at Dover would still be stopped to verify that their cargo meets EU regulations. Moreover, joining the EU Customs Union would prevent the UK from striking independent trade deals with third countries, forcing London to unwind agreements it has already signed with Australia, New Zealand, and the CPTPP trade bloc.

💡 You might also like: The Structural Shattering of Kathmandu

Conversely, joining the Single Market—the model used by Norway through the European Economic Area (EEA)—removes virtually all regulatory friction for goods and services. Yet Norway must accept the "four freedoms" of the EU: the free movement of goods, capital, services, and people. It also pays hundreds of millions of euros annually into the EU budget without having a seat at the table when laws are drafted. For a country of 68 million people with one of the world's largest economies, becoming a non-voting rule-taker on that scale is widely seen across Westminster as unworkable.

Potential Reversal Mechanism Primary Economic Benefit Core Political Obstacle Feasibility in the Near Term
Veterinary / SPS Agreement Eliminates most border checks on food, plants, and live animals; eases Irish Sea trade. Requires dynamic alignment with EU food rules and oversight by the European Court of Justice. Moderate to High — Strong mutual economic incentive, though legally sensitive.
Security and Defense Pact Formalizes intelligence sharing, joint procurement, and crisis response. Minimal domestic pushback; aligns with NATO priorities. High — Viewed as a geopolitical necessity by both London and Brussels.
Youth Mobility Scheme Restores work and study opportunities for 18-to-30-year-olds; eases labor shortages. Perceived by critics as a return to free movement; impacts UK net migration figures. Moderate — Likely requires strict numerical caps and time limits to pass Westminster.
Rejoining the Customs Union Removes rules-of-origin paperwork for manufacturers and supply chains. Strips the UK of an independent trade policy; fails to remove regulatory border checks. Low — Explicitly ruled out by the UK government.
Rejoining the Single Market Restores seamless trade in both goods and financial/professional services. Requires accepting free movement of people, budget contributions, and EU law without voting rights. Very Low — Politically toxic across major British parties.

The Shifting Domestic Calculus

Public opinion in the United Kingdom has moved noticeably since the narrow 51.9% to 48.1% vote to leave in 2016. Polling conducted by organizations such as YouGov and the National Centre for Social Research consistently shows that a clear majority of Britons now view the decision to leave the EU as a mistake, driven largely by concerns over the cost of living, inflation, and economic stagnation.

Yet polling also reveals a deep fatigue with constitutional upheaval. Voters who regret Brexit do not necessarily want another divisive referendum or years of inward-looking parliamentary paralysis. Business leaders echo this sentiment. What companies crave above all else is regulatory stability. Having spent billions adapting their supply chains, IT systems, and compliance departments to the post-Brexit reality, few firms want to go through another massive structural overhaul unless the commercial payoff is guaranteed and immediate.

This creates an asymmetrical dynamic. The macro-level architecture of Brexit—ending free movement, leaving the Common Agricultural Policy, exiting the European Parliament, and establishing an independent trade policy—is firmly embedded. Undoing those pillars would require a generational political shift and a willingness to reopen wounds that neither Westminster nor Brussels has the appetite to revisit.

Instead, the reversal of Brexit is happening at the margins, piece by piece, disguised in the dry, technical language of mutual recognition agreements, regulatory cooperation councils, and veterinary equivalence. A British traveler using e-gates at European airports again, a touring rock band moving gear through France without a carnet, or a Scottish salmon exporter shipping to Paris without a stack of veterinary certificates—these are the tangible ways parts of Brexit can be rolled back. They do not restore the status quo of 2015, nor do they give Britain a voice in shaping European law, leaving the country permanently tethered to the orbit of a regulatory superpower whose rules it can no longer write.

MC

Mei Campbell

A dedicated content strategist and editor, Mei Campbell brings clarity and depth to complex topics. Committed to informing readers with accuracy and insight.