Netanyahu Lost His Majority, Yet Israel’s Opposition Is Still Trapped

Netanyahu Lost His Majority, Yet Israel’s Opposition Is Still Trapped

Benjamin Netanyahu’s right-wing and religious bloc lost its parliamentary majority in Israel’s October 27, 2026 election, finishing with 53 seats in the 120-seat Knesset. Yet the rival Jewish opposition bloc led by former military chief Gadi Eisenkot captured only 48 seats, leaving neither camp anywhere near the 61 mandates required to govern. That deadlock hands the balance of power to two Palestinian-Israeli parties—the Joint List and Ra’am—which surged to a combined 19 seats. On paper, the anti-Netanyahu forces control 67 mandates. In practice, ideological red lines among right-wing opposition leaders have paralyzed coalition building and kept Netanyahu sitting in the prime minister’s chair.

Live election coverage treated the night’s tally as a straightforward reckoning. Ballots came in, Netanyahu’s coalition dropped below 61, and headlines declared his grip broken. Anyone who has covered Israeli politics through five elections in four years knows better. Losing a majority in Jerusalem does not automatically remove a prime minister. Under Israel’s parliamentary rules, the incumbent remains in power as a caretaker until a rival actually swears in a replacement government. When the opposition cannot agree on who is allowed to sit at the cabinet table, a numerical defeat turns into an indefinite lease on office.

The Math Behind a Broken Coalition

To understand why Israel is stuck, look closely at where the votes actually went on October 27. Voters turned out in massive numbers, pushing national participation close to 78 percent, the highest level since 1999. Almost 80 percent of active-duty soldiers cast ballots across hundreds of military bases and combat zones. Despite years of domestic upheaval, the October 7 trauma, and bitter fights over military conscription, Netanyahu’s Likud party still finished first as the single largest faction with 27 seats.

The collapse happened on Likud’s flanks. Netanyahu’s outgoing coalition lost 11 seats overall compared to 2022. While Itamar Ben-Gvir’s Otzma Yehudit held at seven seats and United Torah Judaism kept seven, the ultra-Orthodox Sephardic party Shas dropped sharply to six seats, and Bezalel Smotrich’s Religious Zionism–Zehut ticket won six. Splinter right-wing lists failed to clear the 3.25 percent electoral threshold, burning tens of thousands of nationalist votes that might have saved the ruling bloc.

Political Bloc Constituent Parties Knesset Seats
Pro-Netanyahu Bloc Likud (27), Otzma Yehudit (7), United Torah Judaism (7), Shas (6), Religious Zionism–Zehut (6) 53
Jewish Opposition (Change Bloc) Yashar (21), Together / B’Yachad (12), The Democrats (8), Yisrael Beiteinu (7) 48
Arab-Majority Parties Joint List (11), Ra’am (8) 19

That arithmetic created an instant trap. Eisenkot’s new party, Yashar, emerged as the second-largest force in parliament with 21 seats. Behind him sit former prime minister Naftali Bennett’s Together (B’Yachad) list with 12 seats, Yair Golan’s center-left Democrats with eight, and Avigdor Lieberman’s hawkish Yisrael Beiteinu with seven. Together, those four Zionist opposition factions total 48 mandates. They are 13 seats short of a majority.

How 19 Seats Became the Third Rail

While Jewish parties cannibalized one another, Arab citizens of Israel delivered a political earthquake. Driven by anger over rising discrimination, unchecked crime in Arab towns, and rhetoric from Netanyahu’s ministers, Arab turnout surged. The newly reconstituted Joint List captured 11 seats, while Mansour Abbas’s Islamist Ra’am party climbed to eight. Combined, they gained nine seats over the previous Knesset and claimed 19 mandates—the strongest showing for Palestinian-Israeli parties in the country’s history.

The numbers are blunt. There is no anti-Netanyahu majority without those 19 lawmakers. Yet the very idea of relying on them has split the opposition down the middle.

Only Yair Golan of the Democrats has openly called for formal coalition negotiations with Arab party leaders, arguing that a vote cast in an Arab town carries the exact same constitutional weight as one cast in central Israel. On the other side of the same opposition camp, Avigdor Lieberman has flatly ruled out joining any government that includes Arab parties or even relies on their abstention during a confidence vote. Lieberman insists that an Arab-backed minority government would collapse quickly and hand Netanyahu an easy return to power.

Naftali Bennett has proved even harder to pin down. Controlling 12 crucial seats alongside centrist veteran Yair Lapid, Bennett told Eisenkot privately that he would not back a minority government supported by Arab parties at this stage, signaling a preference for a broad unity government instead. When word leaked that Bennett held a secret two-hour meeting with Netanyahu without telling his opposition partners, panic ripped through the Change bloc. Lapid publicly warned on social media that leaving Netanyahu in office would be "madness," exposing just how fragile the anti-Netanyahu alliance really is.

The Delegitimization Playbook

Netanyahu saw this weakness coming before the polls even closed. On election night, as partial tallies showed Arab parties holding the decisive swing votes, Likud immediately filed formal complaints with the Central Elections Committee alleging that Arab factions had compromised ballot integrity. At three in the morning, standing before party loyalists in Jerusalem, Netanyahu accused the left and Arab parties of trying to "steal" the election and branded any partnership with Palestinian-Israeli lawmakers as treasonous.

Election officials swiftly rejected the fraud claims as baseless. That did not matter. The accusation was never meant to overturn ballot boxes; it was designed to raise the political price for Gadi Eisenkot and Naftali Bennett. By framing Arab parliamentary participation as illegitimate, Netanyahu turned a routine coalition negotiation into a loyalty test for right-wing opposition voters. Every day that Bennett and Lieberman hesitate to sit with Mansour Abbas or Joint List leaders, Netanyahu’s framing gains ground.

Why Haredi Defections Remain a Mirage

Some analysts in Tel Aviv argue that Eisenkot has another exit ramp. If right-wing opposition leaders refuse to partner with Arab parties, could Eisenkot peel away the ultra-Orthodox Haredi parties—Shas and United Torah Judaism—from Netanyahu’s camp?

Look at the legislative reality and that option evaporates. The outgoing coalition nearly tore itself apart over military conscription exemptions for ultra-Orthodox seminary students. Meanwhile, Eisenkot, Bennett, and Lieberman all campaigned heavily on universal military service and ending blanket exemptions after years of grinding war. United Torah Judaism lawmaker Yaakov Asher has already balked at entering formal talks with Eisenkot, and Shas leader Aryeh Deri has vowed to stay loyal to Netanyahu. Even if Haredi leaders wanted to jump ship, Eisenkot could not pay their price on draft exemptions without triggering a revolt from Lieberman and his own secular base.

The Clock Works for the Incumbent

President Isaac Herzog handed Gadi Eisenkot the formal mandate to form a government on November 8, starting a 28-day clock that can be extended by two weeks. Eisenkot is reportedly weighing whether to bring a proposed cabinet to a Knesset vote before his time runs out, even without a guaranteed majority, just to force rival factions to show their hand on the floor.

If Eisenkot fails, Herzog can pass the mandate to another lawmaker—most likely Netanyahu—or watch the Knesset slide toward another snap election in early 2027. That is the outcome Netanyahu is playing for. Every week of stalemate keeps him in the prime minister’s office, preserves his control over state appointments, and lets him campaign against an opposition that won enough votes to replace him yet lacked the nerve to govern. Until Israel’s opposition leaders decide whether they fear Netanyahu more than they fear sharing power with a fifth of the country’s citizens, the man who lost the election still holds the keys.

IG

Isabella Gonzalez

As a veteran correspondent, Isabella Gonzalez has reported from across the globe, bringing firsthand perspectives to international stories and local issues.