The lazy consensus in Canberra is that the horrific car-ramming attack on independent MP Helen Haines proves Australian politicians are simply too accessible. Editorial boards and political strategists hyperventilate about security upgrades, panic buttons, and bulletproof glass for electorate offices. They want to turn local representative hubs into fortified bunkers.
They are entirely wrong.
Building walls between politicians and the public does not solve political violence. It accelerates it. When you lock the doors of democracy, you confirm every paranoid delusion that the political class views ordinary citizens as hostile entities.
The standard narrative treats physical safety and democratic engagement as a zero-sum trade-off. More guards mean less risk, right? Wrong. In policing and public safety, hard-hardening a soft target often shifts the pathology elsewhere while destroying the core utility of the institution. Electorate offices are not corporate executive suites. They are community living rooms. The moment you require an appointment, an ID check, or a security screening just to speak with a local member, you break the social contract that underpins the Australian electoral system.
Let us look at the actual data. According to Australian Federal Police figures, reports of harassment and threatening behavior against office holders have climbed steadily, moving from 951 incidents to over 1,067 in recent cycles. That trend is distressing. But ask yourself what driving politicians behind high fences achieves. It starves them of reality.
I have spent years watching institutions panic-spend on security infrastructure, blowing millions on architecture that screams paranoia while failing to address root behavioral causes. Physical barriers create psychological distance. When politicians stop running into unpredictable, frustrating, messy everyday constituents at the local shops or open electorate office doors, they inhabit a sanitized bubble. They govern in a vacuum. That isolation breeds a different kind of danger: policy detachment that infuriates the public even more.
The intelligence community gets it right, even if the politicians prefer comforting illusions. ASIO Director-General Mike Burgess has repeatedly pointed out that the temperature of our security environment correlates directly with the hostility of our public discourse. Inflamed language and performative parliamentary rage trickle down. The solution to a toxic political culture is not iron gates and bollards. The solution is demanding basic restraint from the people sitting inside parliament house who treat public debate like a blood sport for social media clips.
Consider the alternative. Imagine a scenario where every electorate office across regional and metropolitan Australia transforms into a fortress guarded by private security contractors. Constituents are vetted, scanned, and monitored. What happens to trust? It drops to absolute zero. The vulnerable, marginalized, or desperate citizen—the exact person who relies on an accessible local MP for help navigating a broken bureaucracy—is the first to get filtered out. Meanwhile, a determined attacker will simply bypass the office entirely, because public figures still have to walk down streets, attend community events, and live in the real world.
Fortifying the office protects the ego of the institution, not the safety of the individual.
We must admit the hard truth to our own detriment: an open democracy carries inherent risks. You cannot eliminate all friction from a free society without destroying the freedom itself. When independent MPs like Monique Ryan argue that everyday interactions are precious and that they refuse to hide behind guards, they are defending the soul of the Australian parliament.
Stop trying to fix political violence with architectural cowardice. Turn down the rhetoric in the chamber. Stop treating opponents as existential enemies for short-term electoral gain. Clean up the discourse, keep the doors open, and accept that freedom requires courage, not concrete.