For over six decades, the United States military's capital punishment system has been a sleeping giant. Courts-martial have handed down death sentences, but the actual machinery of execution stalled out completely after 1961, when Army Private John A. Bennett was hanged at Fort Leavenworth for rape and attempted murder.
That long freeze is breaking. Recent legal movements and executive approvals have brought the conversation surrounding military executions crashing back into the public eye, specifically focusing attention on the mechanics of the firing squad. Most people assume military executions went the way of the musket generations ago. They didn't.
The Heavy Shadow of 1945
When people talk about the American military using a firing squad, they almost always point back to Private Eddie Slovik. Back on January 31, 1945, in a quiet French village during the closing months of World War II, Slovik faced a 12-man firing squad after being convicted of desertion. General Dwight D. Eisenhower upheld that sentence to maintain strict discipline in a crumbling war theater.
Slovik remains etched in history because he was the sole American soldier executed for desertion since the Civil War. Yet, military law has always retained broader latitude. Executions for murder, espionage, and mutiny occurred periodically through the mid-20th century, culminating in Bennett’s hanging in 1961. Since then, shifting legal standards, endless automatic appeals, and changing political landscapes created an effective moratorium.
Now, the spotlight is shifting back toward the method itself. The revival of interest in the firing squad is not isolated to military dockets. Several states, including Utah, South Carolina, and Mississippi, have re-embraced the method as lethal injection drugs become increasingly difficult for correctional systems to acquire.
How Military Death Sentences Actually Work
You can't just snap your fingers and carry out a military execution. The process is a bureaucratic and legal marathon designed to prevent wrongful state killings.
First, a case requires a general court-martial consisting of military members who must unanimously agree on a death sentence. Next, the conviction and sentence trigger an automatic multi-layered appeals process. This winds through the service-specific Court of Criminal Appeals, the United States Court of Appeals for the Armed Forces, and eventually crosses paths with federal civilian courts up to the Supreme Court.
Even after every legal appeal fails, the President of the United States must personally review and approve the execution. This requirement places the ultimate moral and political responsibility squarely on the commander-in-chief. Because of these intense procedural safeguards, death rows at places like the United States Disciplinary Barracks at Fort Leavenworth remain mostly stagnant. Convicted service members often spend decades filing petitions rather than facing an imminent date with an executioner.
The Logistics Behind the Method
When a military execution is finally cleared, the mechanics are stark. Under current military regulations, the Secretary of the Army holds the authority to specify the method of execution. While hanging was historically common, modern updates and historical precedents leave room for choices like the firing squad.
A military firing squad typically involves a team of volunteer service members using rifles aimed at a designated target. Just like civilian counterparts in states like Utah, elements such as blank rounds are traditionally integrated into one of the rifles so that no single individual knows definitively whether they fired the fatal shot. It is clinical, organized, and starkly detached from the chaotic battlefield realities where these capital crimes often originate.
Critics argue that reviving these practices drags the nation backward, opening ethical fractures about state-sanctioned death. Proponents maintain that certain crimes committed under the uniform cross a line so severe that military law demands the ultimate penalty to preserve institutional integrity.
The friction between modern human rights standards and centuries-old military codes means this debate isn't going away. As legal hurdles clear and dates loom on the horizon, the armed forces are forced to confront a sobering reality. The machinery of military death, dormant for over half a century, is waking up.